I was recently engaged to design and implement a VMware vSphere architecture solution for a large company that wanted to virtualize Oracle RAC 11g R2 as the back end of a small number of web based online transactional systems. Nothing unusual about that, I hear you say. Well the interesting thing with this project is that the customer intended to use Oracle 11g R2 Standard Edition (18.104.22.168). Up until this point all of the Oracle single instance and RAC systems I had been involved with virtualizing were using Enterprise Edition licenses. This was only a relatively small project and a small part of a very large Oracle landscape, although it was still business critical. The customer was planning to use this project as the test case for virtualizing Oracle RAC 11g R2 with VMware vSphere, with the aim of potentially migrating a significant number of additional database systems off their existing Intel standalone, IBM pSeries and Sun SPARC platforms (which are and will remain using Oracle Enterprise Edition).
This article won’t provide you with everything you need to successfully implement Oracle RAC 11g R2 Standard Edition on vSphere. But it will give you a good overview and some ideas and considerations that could feed into an Oracle RAC virtualization project. Each customer environment is different and there is a lot of tuning at the OS, hypervisor, storage and network layer in order to provide optimal performance for production tier 1 Oracle database environments (roughly on par with implementing Oracle RAC on bare metal). The best practices used during this design are covered in my article titled Deploying Enterprise Oracle Databases on vSphere.
Oracle 11g Standard Edition is great if you have a database that will fit within the product license limits. Currently it is limited to 4 CPU sockets, without any limits on core count, memory or database size. A comparison of the different editions is available on the Oracle website – Oracle Database 11g Editions. What standard edition lacks in comparison to Enterprise are things like resource controls, which is one area where VMware vSphere can add a lot of value. Standard edition does still offer RAC and Enterprise Manager, two very useful and valuable features if you need high availability and management visibility in your database system. By virtualizing with vSphere you also get a load of infrastructure metrics provided out of the box. Oracle 11g Standard Edition in my opinion provides excellent value and features when compared to most other database platforms, provided you have access to DBA’s that can administer it. Be aware this is not a licensing discussion and you will still have to ensure the CPU sockets are correctly licensed in accordance with your licensing agreement.
Benefits and Requirements
My customer was very interested in receiving all the benefits I had outlined in my post on Oracle RAC in an HA/DRS Environment. They were particularly interested in resource controls, Guest OS isolation, rapid provisioning and non-disruptive upgrades. Performance was also very important given the databases were supporting transactional web sites. Having VMware HA restart a RAC node in the case of physical host failure or OS crash was only a bonus as they would be using the Oracle 11g OCI Client with TAF (Transparent Application Failover) with their applications to ensure that all database connections were transparently re-established on a surviving node.
I was tasked with designing a solution that would support OLTP and batch services on each of 5 production Oracle RAC clusters, and 5 development databases, that must fit within the limitations of the Oracle 11g Standard Edition license. Some of the additional requirements and constraints were as follows:
- Must use existing vCenter 4.1 U1 and vSphere 4.1 U1, as that is the current standard platform and there was insufficient time to upgrade to vSphere 5.0
- Only 1Gb/s Network connections are available, and solution must leverage existing network equipment
- Must be able to separate batch and online processing on different RAC nodes for each database
- Must be able to scale to handle future growth, within the limits of the Standard Edition License
- Must use existing storage platform, however two dedicated 8Gb/s array storage ports are available for the new database platforms
- Being as cost efficient as possible was very important for this project
- As these are production tier 1 databases there will not be any overcommitment initially
- An existing hardened RHEL 5.7 base template would be used as the foundation of each Oracle RAC Guest being deployed
Compute Solution Example
Even though the Oracle Standard Edition licensing restricted the design to 4 CPU sockets the I didn’t want to risk 50% of the cluster resources being lost due to a single host failure. As a result single CPU socket hosts with 12 cores per socket (AMD) were specified, resulting in 4 hosts total for the vSphere DRs/HA cluster. This was sufficient for the database workloads that would be supported by the infrastructure as they would be more resource constrained by memory. This allowed for the cluster to have N + 1 hosts logically, with 2 hosts used for Online and Batch/reporting transactions, 1 host used for development, and 1 host (25%) reserved as failover/maintenance capacity.
As a result of specifying 4 hosts the design could meet the memory requirements of the Oracle database VM’s using 96GB per host and 8GB 1333MHz DIMMs, without the need to go to slower and more costly 16GB DIMMs. 96GB per host also aligned well with the customers vSphere Enterprise Plus licensing for the future when they do upgrade to vSphere 5.0 (96GB vRAM entitlement per CPU Socket). This solution was more cost effective, even with the additional HBA and network ports required and provided a better risk profile for the customer, compared to a two host design.
DRS is configured to be fully automated but at the most conservative setting. This allowed automatic placement and vMotion migrations for maintenance mode only. This was drive by the requirement to not over-commit resources and the time a vMotion migration of large VM’s on a single 1 Gb/s Network took (2 minutes). Each RAC Cluster has a DRS Anti-Affinity rule specified to keep each node apart on a different physical vSphere server.
Network Solution Example
Each Oracle RAC Guest would have 3 vNIC’s (VMXNET3) for Public, Private and Backup Networks. The Private Network was used for the RAC Cluster interconnect and had Jumbo Frames enabled. Separate vSwitches were specified each with redundant physical NIC’s for the three main traffic types, Management/vMotion, Public RAC Network, and Private RAC Network. Only a single RAC Interconnect network was used per cluster, although Oracle RAC 11g R2 supports up to 4. Additional Interconnect networks can be added at a later stage with additional redundancy or throughput. However in most cases the redundancy provided by the vSwitch is sufficient.
If you plan to use VMware Distributed Switches then you should consider the benefits of Network IO control and Load Based NIC Teaming. However if you don’t have vSphere Enterprise Plus licenses, or are planning a vCenter Migration at some point, Standard vSwitches (as used on this example project) will work perfectly well.
Storage Solution Example
Each Oracle RAC Guest VM was configured with the maximum 4 SCSI adapters (1 x LSI Logic, 3 x PVSCSI). OS, App, and RMAN virtual disks and mount points were configured on the first SCSI adapter, CRS/Voting and DB Data, Redo, and Archive Log virtual disks configured on the remaining 3 SCSI adapters. A separate LUN and Datastore was configured per SCSI adapter. Each node having it’s own OS/App Datastore, with the other datastores being shared using the vSphere multi-writer functionality (KB 1034165). In total each RAC Cluster had 7 datastores. Each virtual disk was configured to support clustering features, i.e. eager zeroed thick, while the back end datastores were configured as thin provisioned on the SAN. Each physical host had a single dual port HBA and round robin multi-pathing was used for each LUN. All LUNs are presented to all hosts within the cluster. Dedicated array side storage ports were configured for the Oracle RAC vSphere hosts. The LUN queue depths were modified to ensure optimal performance. The Oracle RAC Guests are configured to use Oracle ASM for all shared disks.
VM, Guest OS and RAC Database Solution Example
I configured each VM with between 1 and 3 vCPU depending on workload requirements, and 16GB RAM. Extensive kernel and OS tuning is implemented to ensure optimal performance, this is over and above the Oracle specified minimum settings. Each DB is configured with 8GB SGA and 4GB PGA, with the SGA backed by Huge Pages in the guest OS. Sufficient memory is reserved per VM to cover the SGA and guarantee the minimum acceptable level of performance. As Automated Memory Management is not compatible with Huge Pages it was not used. Huge Pages has multiple benefits including increased performance and no risk the OS will swap out the huge memory pages. Sufficient swap space per Guest OS is configured to cover the amount of memory that is unreserved per VM.
OS Swapping should only ever be observed if there is a host failure in the vSphere cluster or a process failure within the guest. Guests should be sized and configured to not swap memory during normal operations. Allocating more memory over an above the reserved amount (minimum necessary for acceptable performance) can reduce IOPS on the SAN and provide a performance bonus during normal operations. But this memory may be sacrificed during failure scenarios.
Each RAC Database was configured with the standard 3 SCAN (Single Client Access Name) listeners and the SCAN name and IP’s were all configured in DNS to provide DNS Round Robin load balancing. GNS (Grid Naming Service), was not used as DHCP was not available on the networks where RAC was being configured.
We did not have time to implement much in the way of automation to build the Oracle RAC clusters, so the provisioning process was largely manual. However even so it was largely a manual process a single 2 node RAC cluster could be provisioned from scratch, including storage, VM, OS, RAC, DB, and be functional and ready to test in approximately 2 hours. With additional automation this could have been achieved much more quickly.
Validation Testing and Results
As part of the implementation process you should execute validation tests to ensure that the results are as expected, before any of the real applications are loaded into the environments. For this purpose in my example I used Swingbench v2.3 for stress testing, and to provide load during failure scenario testing. Although this is a synthetic workload and not a valid comparison to the real applications that would be supported by these systems it provided a way to test the RAC and vSphere functionality that was important to the customer. Each of the test cases below was run with a standard connection string (//scan-name/service-name) and a TNS connection string using both the JDBC OCI and Thin drivers.
- Baseline VM IO Test (using IO Meter, single vmdk, Windows VM), used to establish guidelines for latency and IOPS as comparison to later tests.
- Baseline DB stress test (to get a result to compare further results against).
- Stress Test during RAC Node vMotion Migration, vMotion migration took 2 minutes, no connection drops
- Graceful shutdown of RAC node during stress test, services and listeners failed over to surviving node, no connection drops using TNS connection string (TAF) as all connections failed over to surviving node, expected connection drops using standard connection string (No TAF), but surviving connections not impacted.
- Power off RAC node during stress test, services and listeners failed over to surviving node, no connection drops using TNS connection string (TAF) as all connections failed over to surviving node, expected connection drops using standard connection string (No TAF), but surviving connections not impacted.
- Power off Host containing RAC node during stress test, services and listeners failed over to surviving node, no connection drops using TNS connection string (TAF) as all connections failed over to surviving node, expected connection drops using standard connection string (No TAF), but surviving connections not impacted, impacted RAC node restarted in approximately 2 minutes on the surviving physical vSphere host. When the powered off physical vSphere host was rebooted the RAC node was automatically migrated back to it using vMotion (thanks to DRS Anti Affinity Rules) to restore cluster redundancy.
During a RAC node failure, even when leveraging TAF, there is a brief pause in transactions while the surviving nodes execute the failover of listeners and connections. This is generally around 15 to 20 seconds in my experience. Selects will resume where they left off, but any uncommitted in-flight updates, inserts or deletes will be re-executed by TAF from the start (refer to Oracle Documentation for more information on TAF functionality and limitations). This is the same for Oracle RAC when deployed on bare metal OS.
When the customer implements vSphere 5 they will have the option of using multiple VMKernel ports for vMotion to get more than 1Gb/s throughput. With large amounts of memory allocated per VM a 10Gbe network, or using multiple vMotion ports in vSphere 5 can greatly improve the performance of migrations, especially when Jumbo Frames is used.
Oracle RAC 11g R2 Standard Edition offers great value for companies that need the availability and features that are provided, and with workloads that can fit within the license limits and you license the infrastructure where Oracle software is installed and/or run. Implementing on a 4 node VMware vSphere HA/DRS cluster with a single CPU socket per host is a great balance of risk, availability and performance, especially for memory or IO constrained workloads. It is a very good place to start with Oracle RAC. When combined with VMware vSphere you can achieve even higher levels of availability, rapid provisioning, resource isolation, non-disruptive hardware upgrades and maintenance, hardware independence for DR, additional system infrastructure metric insight, and great performance.
Oracle RAC runs exceptionally well on VMware vSphere and since 11g R2 v22.214.171.124 (Nov 2010) is fully supported by both Oracle and VMware. By virtualizing Oracle databases and applications on VMware vSphere you can accelerate and increase your ROI while providing predictable performance and service levels. Don’t hesitate to reach out to me if your organization is considering virtualizing Oracle databases or applications on VMware vSphere and would like some help and experience. There is a contact form on the author page.
For additional information on virtualizing Oracle visit my Oracle Page.
This post first appeared on the Long White Virtual Clouds blog at longwhiteclouds.com. By Michael Webster +. Copyright © 2012 – IT Solutions 2000 Ltd and Michael Webster +. All rights reserved. Not to be reproduced for commercial purposes without written permission.